Categories

Showing posts with label Lecturer Notes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lecturer Notes. Show all posts

Theories of Public Expenditure: Paradigm Shifts from Classical Foundations to Modern Insights

Background

Public expenditure plays a fundamental role in economic development, governance, and social welfare. Over the years, economists and political scientists have developed several theories to explain government spending patterns. However, these theories have not remained static — they have undergone major paradigm shifts as new data, methodologies, and perspectives emerged.

This article traces the evolution of these theories, spotlighting the key shifts that transformed how we understand public expenditure.


1. The Classical Paradigm: Wagner’s Law (Late 19th Century)

Paradigm: Economic development leads to larger government.

  • Adolph Wagner proposed that as economies industrialize and grow richer, government activities and expenditures naturally expand.

  • Government spending shifts from traditional roles (defense, law enforcement) to welfare, infrastructure, education, and regulation.

Why it was revolutionary:
This was the first systematic theory linking economic growth with public expenditure growth, establishing a positive and almost automatic relationship.

Reference:

  • Wagner, A. (1883). Economics of Public Finance.


2. The Displacement Effect: Peacock-Wiseman Hypothesis (Mid-20th Century)

Paradigm shift: From smooth growth to “step-like” jumps in expenditure.

  • Peacock and Wiseman challenged the idea of gradual growth by showing that crises like wars or economic shocks cause abrupt increases in spending.

  • Public tolerance for taxation spikes during crises, permanently shifting the expenditure baseline upward.

Significance:
This shifted the view from steady growth to recognizing political and social tolerance as key factors driving expenditure jumps, introducing a more realistic, dynamic pattern.

References:

  • Peacock, A.T., & Wiseman, J. (1961). The Growth of Public Expenditure in the United Kingdom. Princeton University Press.

  • Peacock, A.T., & Wiseman, J. (1967). The Growth of Public Expenditure in the United Kingdom (2nd ed.). Princeton University Press.


3. The Political Economy Turn (Late 20th Century)

Paradigm shift: Public expenditure is shaped by political incentives and institutions, not just economic growth.

  • Theories like Public Choice introduced the idea that politicians and interest groups influence spending decisions for electoral gains or self-interest.

  • Social Contract Theory framed expenditure as part of collective agreements to provide public goods that markets cannot efficiently supply.

Impact:
This broadened the analysis beyond pure economics, integrating political science and ethics to explain expenditure behavior.

References:

  • Buchanan, J.M., & Tullock, G. (1962). The Calculus of Consent. University of Michigan Press.

  • Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. Harvard University Press.


4. Endogeneity and Bidirectional Causality (1990s–2000s)

Paradigm shift: Questioning the direction of causality between economic growth and public expenditure.

  • Contrary to Wagner’s one-way causality, research showed that public expenditure itself can stimulate economic growth.

  • Governments are not passive followers of economic growth; their spending decisions actively influence development.

Why it matters:
This led to more nuanced models that treat growth and spending as mutually influencing variables, demanding careful empirical analysis.

References:

  • Haug, A.A., & Sæther, E.A. (2018). The Wagner’s Law Debate: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Public Economics, 164, 41-51.

  • Zhang, Y. (2015). Re-examining the Relationship between Economic Growth and Government Expenditure. Economic Modelling, 48, 60-68.


5. Institutions and Governance Focus (Early 2000s Onwards)

Paradigm shift: Institutional quality determines the efficiency and impact of public expenditure.

  • Economists like Acemoglu, Johnson, and Robinson emphasized how governance, corruption control, and rule of law affect public spending outcomes.

  • Weak institutions can lead to ineffective or excessive spending without growth benefits.

Significance:
This shifted attention to "how" governments spend, not just "how much," making governance reforms central to public expenditure debates.

References:

  • Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S., & Robinson, J.A. (2001). The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development: An Empirical Investigation. American Economic Review, 91(5), 1369-1401.

  • Kaufmann, D., Kraay, A., & Mastruzzi, M. (2010). The Worldwide Governance Indicators: Methodology and Analytical Issues. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5430.


6. Fiscal Federalism and Decentralization (2000s–Present)

Paradigm shift: Decentralization changes expenditure patterns and accountability.

  • Theories now recognize that shifting spending responsibilities to local governments affects efficiency, equity, and growth.

  • Optimal public expenditure requires balancing central authority with local autonomy.

Impact:
This added complexity, recognizing multiple government layers influencing expenditure decisions.

References:

  • Oates, W.E. (1999). An Essay on Fiscal Federalism. Journal of Economic Literature, 37(3), 1120-1149.

  • Rodden, J. (2006). Hamilton’s Paradox: The Promise and Peril of Fiscal Federalism. Cambridge University Press.


7. Behavioral Economics and Experimental Approaches (2010s–Present)

Paradigm shift: Incorporating human psychology and social norms into public finance theory.

  • Recognizes that taxpayer behavior and public acceptance depend on biases, trust, and social context.

  • This helps explain variations in public support for taxation and expenditure policies.

Why it’s important:
Public finance policies now consider behavioral factors, improving design and communication strategies.

References:

  • Besley, T., & Coate, S. (1997). An Economic Model of Representative Democracy. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112(1), 85-114.

  • Thaler, R.H., & Sunstein, C.R. (2008). Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Yale University Press.


Summary Table of Paradigm Shifts in Public Expenditure Theories

Period Paradigm Shift Key Contributions
Late 19th Century Economic growth drives government size (Wagner’s Law) Government grows naturally with development
Mid-20th Century Stepwise expenditure growth due to crises (Peacock-Wiseman) Political tolerance shifts during crises
Late 20th Century Political economy: politics shapes expenditure Public Choice and Social Contract theories
1990s–2000s Bidirectional causality between growth and spending Government spending also fuels growth
Early 2000s onwards Institutional quality determines expenditure impact Governance reforms key to effective spending
2000s–Present Decentralization changes expenditure dynamics Fiscal federalism theory
2010s–Present Behavioral economics integrates psychology Explains taxpayer attitudes and support

Conclusion

Theories of public expenditure have evolved from simple economic growth models to rich, interdisciplinary frameworks that account for politics, institutions, and human behavior. Recognizing these paradigm shifts enables us to better analyze government spending and design policies that promote efficient and equitable public finance.

Thank You!

Note: This content is re-written of "Theories of Public Expenditure".

Four Growth Theories

Keynesian Economics

Basic of Nepalese Monetary Policy


This blog basically deals with the fundamental concept of monetary policy. This is assumed to be beneficial to beginners.

Meaning of Monetary Policy

It is a set of instruments adopted by the central monetary authority incorporating with the fiscal policy to control the price level. The monetary policy is defined as a discretionary action undertaken by the authorities designed to influence the supply of money and interest rate. Here the policy instruments are; Bank Rate, CRR, SLR, Repo and Reverse Repo, used to control the flow of money supply.

Types of Monetary Policy

Generally, monetary policy has been classified into two catagories:

A. Based on the Objectives: 

There are two sets of objectives viz. 

A.1 Single-Minded Monetary Policy: only aims to set a target either on inflation or nominal GNP growth etc.
A.2 Multi-Objective Monetary Policy: is responsible to accomplish multiple tasks viz. Monetary (money supply, inflation and so on) and Development related activities (supporting to increase government capital expenditure).

B. Based on the Money Supply(M2 )

B.1 Contractionary: Money is infused into the economy.

B.2 Expansionary: Money is defused into the economy.


It should be noted here that Nepal has been adopting the multi-objective monetary policy. 

Goals

The end of the continuum is goal variables, which represent the ultimate objectives of policy and so may be thought of as arguments appearing in the policymakers' objective function. The goals of monetary policy are:
  • Price Stability
  • Economic growth
  • Exchange Stability
  • Full Employment.
Objectives 

It is the specific and precise form of goals of monetary policy. Nepal’s monetary policy objectives are:
  • Maintaining price and external sector stability, financial stability and
  • Facilitating high and sustainable economic growth
  • The top priority for increasing financial access.
Instruments

Instruments are those tools or means of authority which is used to control directly by the relevant policy authority. In the context of Nepalese monetary policy, the list of potential instruments are:
  • Bank Rate,
  • Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR),
  • SLR (Statutory Liquidity Ratio),
  • Repo and Reverse Repo
The rate of these variables changes over a period of time. 

Instruments have been classified into two headings, viz. quantitative and qualitative instruments. 

Under quantitative instruments: Bank Rate, Open Market Operation, CRR and SLR, Refinance Rate and so on. 

Qualitative instruments comprise Marginal Requirement,  Rationing of Credit, Issue of Directives, Moral Suasion, Publicity and Direct Action.

Indicators

Indicators are neither instruments nor goals, but their role is to provide information to the policymaker regarding the current state of the economy.

Illustrations:
  • The economic growth rate remained at 3.6 per cent in 2012/13
  • The inflation rate is estimated to be at 9.9 per cent in 2012/13
  • BOP surplus during the last two consecutive years helped to maintain external stability.
  • The merger of BFIs has been encouraged,
  • High priority has been given to expand inclusive access to finance.
Targets

Values of specific economic variables that the monetary authority seeks to achieve with monetary policy. These targets are usually intermediate targets that are neither an instrument nor a goal, but one which serves as an operational guide to policy. It leads to desirable outcomes for the goal variables. In FY 2013-14, Monetary Policy has the following targets;

  • Economic growth - 5.5 %
  • Inflation at 8 %
  • Foreign exchange reserves -  imports of goods and services at least for 8 months.
  • Growth of broad money by 16%,
  • Domestic credit growth is projected at 17.1 % of which, credit to the government and credit to the private sector is projected to be 12.3 per cent and 18 per cent respectively.
Limitations 
Limitations of Monetary Policy in Developing countries like Nepal.
  • Weak Institutions
  • Political Intervention
  • Lack of Central Bank Independence
  • There exist a Non-Monetized Sector
  • Excess Non-Banking Financial Institutions (NBFI)
  • Existence of Unorganized Financial Market
  • Monetary and Fiscal Policy Lacks Coordination
  • Lack of Transparency and Accountability.

Thank You!!!



Business (Managerial) Economics

CONCEPT OF BUSINESS ECONOMICS
A business is activities perform by any organization through utilizing its financial, human, technical and informational resources to achieve the pre determined objectives. In course of this action business organization must use its resources as efficiently as possible since they are limited in supply and there are costs in acquiring and using them. These include employees (known as labor), machinery and buildings (known as capital), and the land on which the buildings stand. Businesses also have the expertise of their top managers (known as entrepreneurs) who put the labor, capital and land together to produce the finished products most efficiently. Their purpose, amongst other things, is to ensure the business is profitable and grows. If losses are made over time the business will close. Hence, entrepreneurs must think about what and how the business produces, and its long term direction.
Economics is, therefore, the study of how the resources land, labor, capital and enterprise are used or allocated by a country to meet its demands for goods, services and ideas, now and in the future. The resources are employed by businesses or firms and are also known as inputs to the production process, or factors of production.
Investopedia has considered business economics as a field in economics that deals with issues such as business organization, management, expansion and strategy. This studies might include how and why corporations expand, the impact of entrepreneurs, the interactions between corporations and the role of governments in regulation. Business economics explains how the policy adopted by ministry of finance and central bank influence to the business and what kind of world business scenario should be understand so that to expand and build up resistance of own business is answered by the business economics. Basically the important of this subject is to the business managers so that to realize the reality and real practices in the economy and its impact on the business on the two way - positive and negative.
To deal with the role of business economics it is necessary to discuss about the outputs of business. In general, goods and services are considered as an output of any business. But in broad sense ideas and externalities are also included as an business output which in general is included in study. Here we will discuss four output of any business.
Goods
Businesses is known as producers or manufacturer of goods and services. Goods are classified by economists under two main headings, consumer goods and producer goods. Examples of consumer goods include cars, mobiles, chocolate bars, Levis, compact discs, and personal computers if used at home for personal or leisure use. The people who buy them are consumers, or customers and they live in households. In contrast, producer goods, as the name suggests, are used to produce other goods. Examples of producer goods include robots used on assembly lines to manufacture cars, personal computers used in offices for work purposes, and cement mixers on building sites. Many businesses are, therefore, the customers of other businesses which buy their output.
Services
Services consist of the provision of non-physical items. The list of services are endless. It includes knowledge provided by teacher, services given by doctors, entertainment given by the football match between India and Nepal, listening to a live concert, working out at your local gym, staying in a hotel, watching a video of the latest movie (as opposed to the video as a physical object), and so on. In each case, consumers are using or consuming a particular service which gives it a distinctive character compared with a good. A service is used up in the act of consumption although it may live in our memory such as the fond remembrance of dry picnic with friends. Businesses also provide services to other businesses and, in that sense, the latter are consumers of the former’s products. For example cleaning agencies employ staff to clean offices in the evening or early morning when the work force are not there.
Ideas
An idea is intellectual property which can also be bought and sold. Examples include the ideas in a novel or computer software. It is not easy to buy or sell.  Of course, the book and floppy disk containing the ideas are goods.
Externalities
The production process of a business also creates another type of output which occurs to society as a whole but whose effect may not be reflected in a company’s accounts. This type of output is called an externality and may be a benefit to society or a cost. It occurs as a consequence of either production by businesses or consumption by an individual or household. Pollution caused by a factory is the obvious example of an externality and it imposes a cost on society which is known as negative externality. Conversely there may be external benefits, e.g. enjoying a neighbor's garden full of flowers in summer.
Above four output will be possible if they passes through the certain production process. The production process is the use of raw materials or inputs or factors of production, to produce outputs of goods, services and ideas; it may also produce externalities. These inputs consist of: 
Land
This includes not just what its name suggests but also what is found on it and in it – forests and the timber obtained from them, minerals such as crude oil, natural gas and diamonds, and even the fish in the sea. The cost to be paid by employing land, defined in its widest sense, in the production process, is known as rent.
Labor
This is that part of the population who work. Approximately half the Japanese population are too old to work, ill and so unable to work. Though the pace of development of Japan is not declining. They are not worried about having large no of old population but worrying about how to manage the labor they are coming there in. How the work force is determined, and how the number of unemployed are used in economy will be discussed in this book.
Capital
This word is used for machinery, factories, computers, office blocks and information technology. Capital loses its value over time as buildings suffer wear and tear, and so need maintenance, whilst computers become technologically obsolete. So businesses have to set money aside to replace capital as it wears out or becomes technologically obsolete; this is known as depreciation. The term capital is found to distinguish  as a  liquid form (money) and machine. This money may be used to finance a new office block or a new factory. Alternatively it may be used to purchase shares in existing companies. Interest is the return earned from making capital available to a business. Finally, working capital is the term used to describe stocks of components and raw materials waiting to be converted into finished goods, and the finished goods themselves, held in warehouses, for example, waiting to be delivered to retailers for sale.
Enterprise
 Enterprise or entrepreneurship is the resource provided by the entrepreneur. It is the expertise he/she provides to combine the other resources most efficiently to produce the output of goods or services. It requires managerial, financial, inter-personal and strategic abilities if the business is to succeed. Famous examples of entrepreneurs are Binod Chaudhary, Chairman of CG Group, Rupert Murdoch, chairman of the News Corporation which owns publishing and broadcasting businesses around the world, and Bill Gates who co-founded Microsoft.
 
Scarcity of resources
There is a limited supply of resources, i.e. they are scarce or finite, whereas the demand for goods and services produced from them is virtually infinite. This means resources have to be used by businesses and government as efficiently as possible to enable society to best supply what is needed to meet its own needs and demands. Every time a resource is used in one way it means that it cannot be used in other ways. Land used to build a by-pass cannot be used for housing, or as an industrial site, or left alone for the wildlife who live there. An economy therefore seeks to achieve allocative efficiency. This means that it wants to use its resources so efficiently that none are wasted. If it were to make any changes to their use no one could be better off except at the cost of someone else being worse off.
The costs of using resources
Each tutor at your university or college who teaches you is paid a salary or, if employed part time, a wage of between Rs. 4000 and Rs. 10000 per period. This is a cost for the university or college, called the historic cost. Similar costs apply to the use of other resources, as discussed above. For the economist, there is also a second cost to be taken into account, known as the opportunity cost. This is defined as the next best alternative foregone. For example your are learning here at college, because you have chosen to get education first, if you are not studying then you may be working as a assistant manager for a local marketing agency or bank. You forgone the income of working assistant manager so that to study at college. Here your opportunity cost is the tentative income of that post where you may have worked if not studying at college. So why does you study at college instead of working on  tutor teach when he/she could earn more money in business? The answer is that there are non-monetary returns, such as job-satisfaction, that provide sufficient benefit as to offer the best total return i.e. monetary and non-monetary.
RELATION OF BUSINESS ECONOMICS WITH TRADITIONAL ECONOMICS
Economics and Managerial Functions
Economics contributes a great deal towards the performance of managerial duties and responsibilities. Just as biology contributes to the medical professional and physics to engineering, economics contributes to the managerial profession. All other qualification being the same, managers with a working knowledge of economics can perform their functions more efficiently than those without it. The basic function of the managers of a business firm is to achieve the objective of the firm to the maximum possible extent with the limited resources placed at their disposal. It means economics is essentially the subject to study for the logic, tools and techniques of making optimum use of available resources to achieve the given ends.
In performing the function of manager, he has to take a number in conformity with the goals of the firm. Many business decisions are taken under the condition of uncertainty and risk. Uncertainty and risk arise mainly due to uncertain behavior of the market forces, changing business environment, emergency of competitors with highly competitive products, government policy, external influence on the domestic market and social and political changes in the country. The complexity of the present business world adds complexity to business decision making. However the degree of uncertainty and risk can be greatly reduced if market conditions are predicted with a high degree of reliability. The prediction of the future of the business environment alone is not sufficient. What is equally important is to take appropriate business and to formulate a business strategy in conformity with the goals of the firms.
Boumol has pointed out three main contribution of economic theory to business economics.
First, one of the most important thing which the economic theory can contribute to the management science is building analytical models which helps to recognize the structure of managerial problems, eliminate the minor details which might obstruct decision making and help to concentrate on the main issue.
Second, economic theory contributes to the business analysis 'a set of analysis method' which may not be applied directly to specific business problems, but they do enhance the analytical capabilities of the business analysts.
Thirdly, economics theories offer clarity to the various concepts used in business analysis which enables the managers to avoid conceptual pitfalls.
Business economics – How it differs from traditional economics?
Business economics uses largely the same concepts and terminology as economics and addresses many of the same issues. The students might therefore ask how and why a distinction is made between the two. Authors would argue that business economics is worthy of being distinguished and studied separately for a number of reasons. First and foremost, business economics specifically seeks to investigate and analyze how and why businesses behave as they do, and what the implications of their actions are for the industry in which they operate, and for the economy as a whole. Businesses are constrained in their operations by many factors, both internal and external. The internal factors include: the types of resources businesses use, their availability, and how they are combined together in the production process; the nature and levels of the costs businesses incur in producing their goods or services; and the extent to which growth can be achieved internally as opposed to by acquisitions or mergers.
Externally, businesses face constraints from the types of market in which they operate: how competitive are they, for example, and hence how easy to enter or leave; what is the level of demand for the products they produce, and the trends in this demand over time. Other constraints are from policies imposed by the government in relation to competition, minimum wages paid and so on. Additionally, businesses have to work within the constraints imposed on them by the economy. In times of economic recession, for instance, falling consumer demand due to reduced incomes and  rising unemployment may limit the ability of businesses to launch new products, diversify into new markets or even survive. Therefore, business economics seeks to analyze these constraints which face businesses, draw conclusions as to how and why businesses behave as they do, and analyze the implications of such behavior. Business economics also draws on a wide range of different theories from a variety of different disciplines of which economics is just one, albeit the main one. Economics has had a major impact on the development of other intellectual disciplines such as business strategy, organizational behavior, human resource management and marketing. All of these have drawn on it for parts of their theoretical content and, in turn, business economics draws on developments in these other areas.
Business and Economics
Business is an Economic Activity
An economic activities involves the task of adjusting the resources (means) to outputs (ends) or the ends to means. An economic activity may assume different forms such as consumption, production, distribution and exchange. The nature of business differs, depending upon the form of economic activities being undertaken and organized. For example manufacture is primarily concerned with production; the stock exchange business is mainly concerned with the buying and selling of shares and debenture; the business of government is to run the administration. The government may also own control and manage public enterprises. The business of banks is to facilitate transactions with short term and long term funds. These examples can be easily multiplied. The point to be noted is that each business has a target to achieve and for this purpose each business has some resources at its disposal. Sometimes the target has to be matched with the given resources and sometime the resources have to be matched with the given target. Either way the task of business is to optimize the outcome of economic activities.
A business Firm is an Economic Unit
A business firm is essentially a transformation unit, it transform inputs into outputs of goods and services or a combination of both. The nature of input requirements and the types of output flows are determined by the size, structure, location and efficiency of the business firm under consideration. Business firms may be different sizes and forms. They may undertake different types of activities such as mining, manufacturer, farming trading transport, banking etc. The motivational objective underlying all these activities is the same viz., profit maximization in the long run. Profit is essentially a surplus value- the value of outputs in excess of the values of inputs or the surplus of revenue over the cost, a business firm undertakes transformational process to generate this surplus value. The firm can grow future if the surplus value is productively invested. Firm therefore carefully plans the optimum allocation of resources to get optimum production. The entries process of creating, mobilization and utilization of the surplus constitutes the economic activity of the business firm.
Business Decision Making is an Economic Process
Decision making involves making a choice from a set of alternative courses of action. choice is at the root of all economic activity. The question of choice and evaluation arises because of the relative scarcity of resources. If the resources had not been scared an unlimited amount of ends could have been met. But the situation of resource constraint is very real. A business firm thinks seriously about the optimum allocation of resources because resources are limited in supply and most resources have alternative uses. The firm therefore intends to get the best out of given resources or to minimize the use of resources for achieving a specific target. In other words when inputs is the constraining factor, the form's decision variable is the output. And when output is the constraining factor then the firm's decision variables is the input. Whatever may be the decision variable, procurement or production, distribution or sale, output or input, decision making is invariably the process of selecting the best available alternative. That is what makes it an economic pursuit.

Thank You!!!

National Income Accounting


A)  Introduction

National income accounting plays a prominent role in economic theory. While talking about national income somewhere we became little bit in confusion with the term national product. So initially we will find the right point to know about national income and national product first.
 
Both national income and product are flow quantities related to a given time dimension. While national product refers to the flows of final goods and services produced during any given period of time. National income represents the flow of total factors of earning available to purchase the net flow of goods and services in the economy during any given time period, generally one year. It is generally assumed that national income and national product becomes equals only if the market is functioning perfectly.

G. Ackley has defined national income considering equivalent to national product as the economy's total current output of goods and services valued at the market prices they command. National income reconciles of the following heading:
a)   Wages, salaries, commissions, bonuses and other forms of employee earning (before deduction of taxes and social security contribution)
b)  Net income from rentals and royalties
c)  Interest Income
d)  Profit including corporation, partnership or proprietorship;
                Paid out to the owners or retained in the business,
                Before deducing taxes based on income.

B)   Concepts of National Income
 A study of concepts of national income follows from the definitions of different terminology used. We discuss them as follow:

a) Gross Domestic Product (GDP): GDP is the total market value of all currently produced final goods and services produced within a given geographical region, namely country, during a given period of time, generally one year. GDP includes the four components viz. consumption expenditures (C), investment expenditure (I), government expenditure (G), and net exports
(X – M).
Mathematically, GDP = C + I + G + (X - M)
        Where,     C= Consumption Expenditure
                        I= Investment Expenditure
                        G= Government Expenditure
                        X-M= Net Export.


Real And Nominal GDP
A sampling technique is used to estimate it in two steps; first, counting the number of final goods services and structures produced in the country (Qi), and second assigning the dollar value of output (Pi). If assigning dollar value is done using the current market price of outputs, it is called GDP in current prices or nominal GDP.  Nominal GDP measures currently produced goods and services produced within the economy at market prices. If the value of output assigns constant prices from base year, then it gives the real GDP. Real GDP is also called GDP in terms of goods or GDP in constant prices or GDP adjusted for inflation. This means while calculating nominal GDP both i). Quantities of goods and services and, ii). Price of the respective goods varies but in case of real GDP,  i). Quantities of goods and services varies but, ii). Price of the respective goods and services remains constant.
In short,
Real GDP = Nominal GDP / GDP Deflator
Where GDP Deflator = Current year's price index  / Base year's price index (=100)

 
b)   Gross National Product. (GNP) : GNP is the market value of all currently produced final goods and services produced by domestically owned factors of production during a period of time, generally one year. In other word, GNP is the total output of final goods and services produced during any given period of time by the residents of a country.
Mathematically,
        GNP = C + I + G + (X - M) + NFIA
                = GDP + NFIA
Where  NFIA = Net factor income from abroad.

c)   Net National Product (NNP): NNP is the market value of all final goods and services after allowing for capital consumption allowances or depreciation. NNP is also known as the National Income at market prices.
Mathematically,
                NNP = GNP - CCA or Depreciation
Where   
        CCA = Capital Consumption Allowance
       
 d)   National Income (NI) : National income is that part of NNP which we obtain deducing indirect taxes and summing up the subsides given. NI is also known as the NNP at factor cost. Mathematically,
        NI = NNP - Indirect taxes + subsidies
               = NNP at factor cost.
        If National Income is measured then we will sum up all the income received by the factors of production(i.e. labor, land, capital and organization) owned by the residents of a country.
i)     Wages salaries, commissions, bonus and other forms of employee earning (before deducing of taxes or social security contribution.)
ii)    Net income from rental and royalties
iii)   Interest Income
iv)   Profit, whether of a corporate, partnership or proprietorship whether paid out to owners or retained in the business, and before deduction of taxes based on income.

 e)   Personal Income (PI) : This is the sum of all income actually received by all individuals or households during a given year. This can be obtained as;
              PI    = National income
                        - Social security contribution
                        - Corporate Income Tax
                        - Undistributed profits
                        + Transfer payment
                        + Interest on public Debt.

f)  Disposable Income (DI): The income which remains after subtracting direct taxes from personal income is called disposable income. Thus, 
Disposable Income (DI) = Personal Income - Indirect Taxes.
                                        OR                                                                                     
                                 DI        = Consumption + Saving.




Methods of Measuring National Income Accounts
        Measurement of National Income has been done with the help of three methods viz. Expenditure, Income and Product method. All three approaches give the identical measurement of current economic activities.

A)  Expenditure Method
        This method measure the national income of a nation through the expenditure side. To calculate the national income, initially GDP has calculated which includes the personal consumption expenditure, gross private domestic investment, government purchase of goods and services and transaction with international market. Summing up all these four components gives us the GDP of a nation. To reduce GDP into Net National Product at Factor cost, necessary adjustment are made and this process of calculating National income can be shown as following table:

S.N
Expenditure Headings
Amount
in Rs
Billion
1.
Personal Consumption Expenditure (c)


55

i) Durables
20



ii) Non-Durables
25



iii) Services
10


2.
Gross Domestic Private Investment (I)


45

i) Business fixed investment

28


·Non- residential structures
17



·Producer's Durable equipments
11



i) Residential Investment

10


ii) Inventory Investment

7

3.
Government Purchase of Goods and Services (G)


65
4.
Net Export (X - M)


-10

i) Exports (X)

23


ii) Imports (M)

33


GDP = C + I + G + (X - M) + NFIA
55 + 45 + 65 –10 = 155
5


          = GNP
          – Depreciation or CCA


15
160

= NNP
          – Indirect Taxes
          + Subsidies


3
2
145


          = National Income or
          NNP at factor cost


144


B)   Income Method
        According to this approach, the factor earning of the economy is the sum total of real, wages, interest and profit. The incomes are earned there from property or through work. It can be presented on the following table.
S.N.
Headings
Amount is Rs. Billion
1.
Consumption of Employees
75
2.
Proprietor's Income
26
3.
Rental Income of Persons
18
4
Corporate Profits
15
5.
Net Interest
10

= NNP at factor cost or National Income
+ Indirect Taxes - Subsides
144

+ 3 – 2

= NNP
+ CCA or Depreciation
145
+15

= GNP
- NFIA
160
-5

GDP
155
Conceptual Clarity
1)    Consumption of Employee: It includes those wages and salaries paid by the government and business to the supplier of labor. It is the income of the workers (excluding the self-employed) and includes wages, salaries. employees benefits(including contribution of employers to the pension plans), and employers contribution to the social security.

2)    Proprietor's Income: Under this heading income of non incorporated self-employed are included. It is the net income of sole proprietorship and partnership. the proprietor of an owner operated business supplies labour, capital and perhaps land and buildings to the business. it is difficult the  split the income earned by owner operated business into compensation for the labor, payments for the use of the capital etc. Thus, NI accounts combine of all these into a single category as proprietor's income. E.g. the amount that the owner of a cafe or a farm earns in a year is often considered by the owner of a cafe or a farm earns in a year is often considered by the owner of a cafe or a farm earns in a year is often considered by the owner if the business as a 'profit', yet most of that 'profit' is a payment to the owner for his labor.

3)    Rental Income: Rental income includes the rent of land, other rented proprietor, income and the estimated rent of all such assets are used by the owner themselves. It includes a) all rents received by households for lease of land and other properties, and b) an imputed value for rent of owner occupied housing.

4)    Corporate Profits: Corporate profits represent the remainder on corporate income after wages, interest and other costs have been paid. Corporate profit are used to pay taxes levied on corporations such as the corporate income tax, and to pay dividents to the shareholders. The rest of corporate profit after taxes and dividends called retained earnings, kept undistributed by the corporation. Corporate profit includes the amount that corporations pay in the form of the corporate income tax, the amount they pay stockholders in the form of dividends and the amount they save or retained within the business.

5)    Net Interest: This category includes only that interest which is paid out by the business sector. This category does not include the interest that consumers pay because it is not considered as a payment stemming from the production of output not it does include interest that the government pays on its debts. Government interest payments are seen as transfer because no output is produced that the interest supports.

6)    National Income: National income is the summing up of all the above five category. It is also known as NNP at factors cost.

7)    Indirect Taxes: Those taxes imposed by government are called as indirect taxes whose burden is shifted to the other people. VAT, sales tax, excise duties etc are the eg. of indirect taxes. Therefore they must be added to measure NNP of a country.

8)    Subsidies: It is a financial support given by the government to private firms and owned enterprises.
9)    Depreciation: Depreciation is known as the consumption unit of fixed assets or capital. Due to the continuous use of capital assets it tears out, so we deduce same amount from its initial value.
C.   Product Method
        This method measures the NI at the phases of production in the circular flow. It is often called the Industry of Origin method. Under this method economy is classified into various sectors namely, agricultural, industrial, manufacturing, foreign transaction etc. In each sector we can make an inventory of goods produced and find out the end value addition goods. Under the product methods there are two approaches;
1.     Final Product Approach
2.     Value Added Approach
1.   Final Product Method:
        Final Product Method is that one, that is produced and sold for consumption and investment GDP excludes the intermediate goods that are used to produce other goods. According to this approach, GDP is estimated by finding the market value of final goods and services produced in an economy during a period of one year.
Steps
a)     GDP at Market Price = Market values of all Final goods and services
b)    GNP at Marked Price = GDP at Market Price + NFAI
c)     NNP at Market price = GNP at Market Price - Depreciation or CCA
d)    National Income or NNP at factor cost = NNP at Market Price - indirect taxes + subsidies.

2.   Value Added Methods:
        In this method the value added at the different stages of production is counted for calculating NI. Value added is the difference between the value of materials output and inputs at each stage of production.
        Value Added = Sales Value of Output - Cost of Intermediate Goods (= Sales - Cost).
When we add such difference of all the industries in the economy. We get the GDP of a nation.
Steps.
a)   Industrial classification:
        This method divides all producing sector in the economy into three category, according to their activities they perform. They are
i)     Primary Sector (Agriculture called activities)
ii)    Secondary Sector (Manufacturing, Construction electricity etc.)
iii)   Tertiary Sector (Banking Transport, Insurance etc.)
b)   Computation of Gross Value Added:
        Gross Value Added = Value of output - Cost of intermediate goods = Revenue - Cost
c)   Calculation of GDP:
        GDP is the sum of gross value added of all sectors including classified above sectors, gives GDP at factor cost.
        GDP at factor cost = Sum of all gross value added of all sectors
        GNP at factor cost = GDP at factor cost + NFIA
        NNP at factor cost
or    National Income = GNP at factor cost - Depreciation or CCA.
        Measurement of the Final Product by the Value - Added and the Market Price Method


Farmer
Miller
Bakery
Consumers
Total Value
(in Billion)
Purchase of inputs
0
25
30
45
45

­
Zero cost to farmer initially


Consumers buy not to sale but to consume
 ­
Final Product
Sales
25
30
45
-
¯
Value - Added
25
5
15
-
45
        In above table value added by each one of the three producers is the value of his total money sales minus the cost of the inputs bought by him from the other producers. The total money value added is Rs 45 Billion which is also the money value obtained by valuing the total output of bread at its market price.



2)   Limitations of National Income Measurement
        The calculation of national income of a country involves certain difficulties or limitations. These are mainly due to the non-availability or partial availability of detailed and reliable statistics about the different sector of the economy. These limitations are discussed classifying into two catagory i.e a) Conceptual Difficulties and b) Statistical Difficulties.

 Conceptual Difficulties.

i)     National income is always measured in terms of money but there are so many goods and services that cannot be measured in term of money. Eg. painting as a hobby, bringing up of children etc.

ii)    problem of double counting arises while counting national income which arises from the failure of to distinguish properly between a final and intermediate product, flour is intermediate product for bakery but final to the household.

iii)   National income account includes only those goods and services produced by using legal activities but in reality there may have various activities of production that has been doing illegal activities. Thus, accounting national income may reduce the size of the economy.

iv)   Capital gains or losses which accrue to property owners by increasing or decreasing in the market value of their capital assets or changes in demand are excluded from the GNP because such changes do not result from current economic activities.

v)    In calculating NI, price changes fail to keep stable the measuring rod of money for national income. When the price level in the countries rises, the national income also shows an increasing even though the production might have fallen, and country with a fall in price level the national income shows a decline even through the production might have gone up. Thus national income data are misleading and unreliable.

vi)   National income accounting may be difficult to estimate correctly from public service workers. National income cannot measure the service of police and military at the time of war and during peace.

vii)  The national income accounting does not take into consideration the actual cost of production of a commodity.

                      Statistical Difficulties

                  i.         Accurate and reliable data are not adequate, as far as output in the subsistence sector is not completely informed. Small scale and cottage industries also do not report their targets. Indigenous bankers do not furnish reliable data and so on.

                ii.         Due to the large regional diversities they have different culture , customs, languages etc. also create the problems in computing the national income. People elsewhere do not cooperate to collect data that is needed for NI measurement.

              iii.         Data should be complied collecting from the different sector of the nation. Compiled data may not give the actual result and moreover in developing nations untrained and undertrained staff are still in the bureau of statistics which is also another hindrance of NI measurement.

 Numerical Example
1. Consider an economy produces three goods: apple, bread and computers.  The quantities and prices per unit in various years are as follows:
 Variables
Year 2009
Year 2010
Year  2011


Qt.
Price in Rs.
Qt.
Price in Rs.
Qt.
Price in Rs.

Apple
1,000
30
1000
40
1500
40

Breads
1500
20
1500
40
1500
40

Computer
10
10000
10
15000
10
15000


i.       Find the nominal GDP in each year?
ii.       Assume 2009 as the base year and calculate real GDP in each year?
iii.       Find the economic growth in 2010 and 2011?
Solution:
i) Nominal GDP of Each Year


Year 2009
Total MP of each goods
Qt.
Per unit Price in Rs.
Apple
1,000
30
1000x30=30000
Breads
1500
20
1500x20=30000
Computer
10
10000
10x10000=100000
Nominal GDP of 2009 =
160000


Year 2010
Total MP of each goods
Qt.
per unit Price in Rs.
Apple
1000
40
1000x40=40000
Breads
1500
40
1500x40=60000
Computer
10
15000
10x15000=150000
Nominal GDP of 2010 =
250000


Year  2011

Qt.
per unit Price in Rs.
Total MP of each goods
Apple
1500
40
1500x40=60000
Breads
1500
40
1500x40=60000
Computer
10
15000
10x15000=150000
Nominal GDP of 2011 =
270000
  
To sum up, Nominal GDP 

Years
Nominal GDP
2009
 160000
2010
 250000
2011
 270000


ii) To calculate real GDP,

We know that RGDP = Nominal GDP/GDP Deflator
GDP Deflator = Current Year Price/Base Year Price
Then,
 RGDP = Nominal GDP x(Base Year Price / Current Year Price)

Well, we have nominal GDP, now need to calculate Price Index first

Consider that 2009 is the base year, then total price of that year is 
= 30+20+10000
=10050
As 2009 is base year then we consider that 10050 = 100
In 2010 price index would be = 100x(15080/10050) = 149.60 = 150(appro.)
In 2011 price index would be = 100x(15080/10050)
Note that we have develop price index following the simple unitary rule.
Now we get
Year
Nomina GDP
Price Index
RGDP
2009
160000
100
160000
2010
250000
150
250000x(100/150)=166666.67
2011
270000
150
270000x(100/150)=180000

iii)
Economic growth of 2010 = (change in RGDP/RGDP of 2009)  x100.

Follow this formula (this is a simple formula that we use to calculate percentage in our business) get the answer.

  3)  System of National Income Accounting and Sector Accounting:
        This section deals with the process of measuring product and income originating in the business, government, household and the rest of the world of an actual economy. In the process, here we will find out the relationship between income and product in an economy, but also setup a system of national accounts which will trace the principal economic flow among the major sectors of the economy. We begin the sector accounting with the business sector.
A)  Business Sector:
        We can derive the business sector's account through the manipulation and consolidation of the ordinary profit and loss of business firm. There are basically three heading involves.
a)     Gross revenue from sales plus other non operating income
b)    Cost of Goods Sold
c)     Profit
        To present the business sector account we divide above three heading in various subgroup depending upon the nature of business sector. Here we present the product account on the basis of U. S. Economy as presented by G. Ackley.
Consolidated Business Income and Product Account
a)   National Income Originating in          Business
·       Compensation of employees: Wages salaries and supplements
·       Net Interest
·       Net Dividends
·       Corporate undistributed profit
·       Corporate profit tax liability
·       Proprietor's income
·       Rental income of persons
a)   Consolidated Net Sales
·       To persons.
·       To government
·       To abroad
·       To business on capital account
b)   Increase in Inventories

b)   Adjustments of Market Price
·       Indirect business tax liability
·       Business transfer payments
·       Current surplus of government enterprises Less: subsidies

c)   Net National Product originating in business

d)   Depreciation

Total Expenditure
Total Receipts
B)   Government Sector
        In this sector we present a simple statement of government receipts and expenditures and have shown in following table:
Government Receipts and Expenditures Account
a)   Purchases of goods and services
·       From business
·       From abroad
·       Wages salaries and supplements
a)   Taxes
·       Personal tax receipts
·       Corporate profit tax accurals
·       Indirect Business tax accounts
b)   Transfer payments
·       To persons
·       To foreign
b)   Contributions for social insurance
·       Employer
·       Personal
c)   Net Interest Paid

d)   Subsidies
      Less: Current surplus of    government enterprise.

e)   Surplus or deficit on income and product account

Government Outlays and Surplus in Total
Government Receipts in Total


c)   Household Sector
        Household sector includes nonprofit institutions serving consumers, such as non-governmental but non-profits schools, colleges and hospitals; voluntary associations such as Red cross, Trust funds benefiting consumers; and private pension and welfare fund including household in usual sense. Account of Household sector has shown below in table.
Personal Income and Outlay Account
a)   Personal Consumption Expenditure
·       Purchase from business
·       Wages, salaries and supplements
·       Purchases from abroad
·       Interest paid
a)   Wages, Salaries And Supplements   from
·       Business
·       Government
·       Households
·       Abroad
Less employee & employer social Insurance contribution.
b)   Personal Taxes
b)   Rental income of person
c)   Personal Saving
c)   Proprietors income;
·       Business and Professional
·       Farm
d)   Dividends
e)   Personal interest income
f)    Transfer payment
·       Government
·       Business
Total personal outlay and saving
Personal Income
d)   Foreign Transaction Account:
        Generally, rest of the world (row) sector has been used instead of foreign transaction account, But we have used foreign transaction account here to represent 'row' as well as below:
Foreign Transaction Account:
Exports of Goods and Services
Import of goods and services
Transfer payment by government
Net foreign investment
Receipts from abroad
Payments to abroad
  Thank You!!!